In 2021, Grove Presbyterian Church celebrates its 166th anniversary. The Church’s roots, however, are much older and deeper, coinciding with the birth of Danville and of our Nation.
(Updated 1/13/2021) In the 1770’s, when the area was predominately occupied by Native Americans, a small intrepid group of settlers, mostly of Scotch-Irish Presbyterian background, acquired land here. Most prominent among these was General William Montgomery, a Revolutionary War hero who had purchased 600 acres, now a large component of the Borough of Danville but known then as the Mahoning Settlement. In 1775 a plot of about four acres was purchased by four settlers designated as trustees in order to provide sites for a Presbyterian school, church and burial ground, land that is occupied today by the Grove Church campus and Memorial Park (formerly the Presbyterian Cemetery). Illustrative of these early times, one of the trustees, Robert Curry, was killed and scalped and his wife taken captive a few miles from the settlement by a Native American war party. A log schoolhouse was first erected on the site and then, around 1790, a log building for the Mahoning English Presbyterian Church, which had been formally organized in 1785. The congregation had worshiped in General Montgomery’s home and barn until the church was completed, at which time Reverend John Boyd Patterson became their first permanent Pastor. Growth of the congregation and the community, now named Danville, led in 1826 to the replacement on the same site of the Log Church by a rather plain and evidently insubstantial building known simply as the Brick Church. Situated in a grove of stately oaks, its features included a tall pulpit, high-backed pews, and a manually operated pipe organ. By the 1850’s, membership had increased, the church building had deteriorated and, perhaps more important, the homes and activities of the majority of the congregation now centered in the area between the canal and the Susquehanna River, leaving the Brick Church in a backwater. Consequently, the present Mahoning Presbyterian Church was built and completed in 1854, and the congregation moved there. A significant number of the members, however, happily recalled worshiping in their old, if dilapidated, church in the grove. In 1855, an amicable division was formally agreed to, and permission was granted by the Presbytery on October 2, to form a new Congregation called the Mahoning English Presbyterian Church North. A few years later, the name was changed to the Grove Presbyterian Church.
Members of the newly-formed Church, numbering about one hundred, promptly set to work renovating their Brick Church in the grove, worshiping in local halls until the job was completed in 1856. Reverend Charles Jewett Collins was their first Pastor. In 1858 they built a two-story brick Manse in Victorian style to house the Pastor and his family. It was clear, however, that a new church building was needed; hence the old brick edifice was torn down around 1871. Some of its materials were incorporated over the next four years in construction of the present Gothic church. The Chapel was completed first, and the congregation worshiped there until the Sanctuary and its magnificent steeple were finished. Finally, on October 24, 1875, the new church was dedicated with much ceremony. During the remainder of its first century, the Grove Church continued to grow in membership, educational activities and facilities. Fourteen Pastors succeeded Reverend Collins, their terms ranging from three to eleven years. At the turn of the century, the Chapel was remodeled and an addition built on its south side to house the Church School, a social hall and a kitchen. Originally installed in the balcony, the pipe organ was moved to the front of the Sanctuary. Electric lights and central heating displaced gas lamps and coal-burning stoves. Faced with the gradual loss of the original oak grove, members planted the maples which now shade the grounds. In 1926 the stained glass windows in the Sanctuary today were installed, replacing darker ones, possibly from the old Brick Church (examples of these are still visible in the west wall of the Chapel). In 1955, the Grove Church reached its one-hundredth birthday. This was celebrated by a dramatic pageant in which some current members of the congregation participated.
During the past fifty-plus years, six Pastors each have contributed in varied ways to the continual spiritual, physical and governmental development of the Grove Church. Reverend Joseph Kuehne, Jr. was Pastor from 1952 until 1958. He was succeeded in 1959 by Reverend David Mitchell Thompson who had been born in the Manse while his father was Pastor here. Reverend Frank Henry Noll served from 1972 until his retirement in 1985. He was followed by Reverend Robert August Koenig who remained through 1988. The Reverend Doctor Robert John Andrews was installed in 1989, retired in 2016 with his last service being on Christmas Day. This was followed by a prolonged search for a new pastor. During 2016 and half of 2017, the Rev. Steve Cureton served as interim pastor. Rev. Cureton was then called to serve as Executive Presbyter of the Northumberland Presbytery. For the second half of 2017, Grove relied on pulpit supply. In 2018, the Reverends Sally Dries, Steve Cureton, and Robert Andrews, Pastor Emeritus served as co-interim pastors and continued through August of 2019. The Rev. Jason Allan Clapper was called to Grove during the summer of 2019, began preaching in September, and was officially installed in November. Under the guidance of these capable men and equally capable and devoted leaders from the congregation, much has changed in the life of the Grove Church while, at the same time, its firm foundation in Presbyterian faith and worship has persisted. Most readily visible are the physical changes. In 1985 the Manse, renamed the Kirk House, was converted to church offices for the Pastor and Administrative Team. Kristin Keller currently serves as part-time administrative assistant and Lisa Padner is the financial secretary. Of primary significance was the completion in 1996 of an extensive building program which included a two-story addition, clad in Shickshinny gray stone matching the original church building, to the east side of the old Chapel. This houses educational, meeting, nursery, choir and resource rooms and restrooms. Simultaneously the Chapel basement and entrances on its east and west ends were reconfigured and new parking areas added. The Sanctuary and its vestibule were extensively refurbished over several months in 1997-98, most of the work being done in the pulpit area and on the organ. The latter was disassembled and later reinstalled with a new repositioned console using many new pipes as well as some of the old ones. A beautifully landscaped Memorial Garden in the grove to the west of the church was added in 2004. Other significant enhancements included a new baptismal font, carillon, sound system, handicapped ramp, ceiling fans, kitchen, steeple illumination, air conditioning, and livestreaming capability. Sandra Lewis became the inside custodian in 1984 and currently member Dave Sanders serves as the sexton. Grove Church acquired the lot and two-story house just west of the campus; it houses two rental units and North Branch PA Young Life. The last half-century has also witnessed many changes in the worship, mission activity and community involvement of the Grove Church. Communion, observed only annually during the earliest years in the Log Church and then quarterly and on Maundy Thursday during most of Grove’s history, became a monthly feature in the 1990’s at the 11:00 AM services, and it was a weekly feature at the 8:30 AM services until the 8:30 AM service was discontinued mid-2016. The Spire, a monthly newsletter, was produced for nearly 30 years. The vigorous Church School with its devoted teachers has continued to inspire and educate Grove’s children and youth. It is currently led by Lynne A. Pabst, Director of Children’s Ministries, who also directs children’s choirs with recent help from Kristen Zhang. The Senior Choir has been a central feature of worship at the Church since its origin. Its loyal members and long-serving Directors, most recently Brian Crane, have sustained the congregation’s love of sacred music. Anna Kinn, Dr. Frederick G. Brown, and now Joy Christian have been the principal organists during this period. The Grove Church’s involvement in the community, while always present, has increased in recent years. Participation in the Community Food Bank, Good Samaritan Mission, Jubilee Kitchen, Gate House, Women’s Center, and Recreational Authority involves many at Grove. All Pastors have continued a visitation mission to those hospitalized or confined. Reverend Andrews led annual mission trips to Honduras, and the Youth Group has undertaken similar missions to various communities in the United States. The central theme has been service to those in need. As a result of several significant changes in church governance, members of the congregation have become increasingly involved. The Board of Deacons was founded in 1960, and in 1967, Elizabeth Drumm and Ethel Hinkel were the first women to be ordained as Elders. A unicameral system was adopted in 1973 when the Board of Trustees merged with the Session whose membership was then expanded to fifteen. Amanda Leicht, the present Clerk of Session, is the latest of a long line of leaders of the congregation. Many organizations have contributed to fellowship and outreach activities. The Women of Grove, now merged with the Fellowship Committee, was established in the 1960’s with its roots in the Senior and Junior Guilds of an earlier era; it enriched many areas of church and community life. The Joyliners Couples Club had a long history of sponsoring dinners, square dances, and other social activities. Various programs have drawn together the youth of the congregation for worship, mission trips, and assistance at church functions. A Boy Scout troop, meeting at and sponsored by the Grove Church, was inaugurated in 1989. Several other troops have since then been hosted at the church. Bible study sessions, lectures and seminars by the Pastor and others on theological and intellectual topics, a book club, picnics, breakfast groups, family programs and church dinners have all added to the spiritual and fellowship life of the Church. Asked to comment on the Grove Church today, the recently retired Reverend Andrews cited strong and deeply committed leadership by lay members, both in the Church and in the community. Equally important, he felt, was the congregation’s open-mindedness, willingness to listen to the views of others, and acceptance of faith as a continual journey. To these current strengths one might add the inspiration, spiritual leadership and wise guidance of Grove’s Pastors past and present; magnificent church buildings; a lovely Memorial Garden and our historic tree-shaded grounds. While the Grove Church moves forward into the twenty-first century, its rich and ancient heritage continues to remind us that in this world God’s work must truly be our own.
1856 - 1865 : Charles Jewett Collins
"A Brief History of Grove Presbyterian Church", written by Frederick L. Jones, Jr. 1. Church Registry and Minutes of the Session of the Grove Presbyterian Church
1866 - 1869 : James Gordon Carnachan
1869 - 1874 : Reuben Van Pelt
1874 - 1879 : William A. McAtee
1880 - 1883 : John Boyd Grier
1883 - 1888 : James H. Simonton
1889 - 1892 : Elliot Chidsey Armstrong
1892 - 1902 : William A. McAtee
1903 - 1910 : William Charles McCormick
1910 - 1916 : William Kerr McKinney
1916 - 1919 : Hugh Gage Moody
1919 - 1924 : William C. Thompson
1924 - 1930 : Raymond David Adams
1930 - 1941 : John C. Moore
1942 - 1951 : James J. Mentzer
1951 - 1958 : Joseph Kuehne, Jr.
1959 - 1972 : David M. Thompson
1972 - 1984 : Frank Henry Noll
1985 - 1988 : Robert August Koenig
1989 - 2016 : Robert John Andrews
2019 - : Jason Allen Clapper
2. Brower, D.H.B: Danville, Montour County Pennsylvania: A Collection of Historical and Biographical Sketches Harrisburg, Lane S. Hart, 1881 (Reproduced 1976 by Unigraphic, Inc.)
3. Battle, J.H., ed: History of Columbia and Montour Counties, Pennsylvania. Chicago, A. Warner & Co., 1887 (Reproduced 1974 by Unigraphic, Inc.)
4. Diehl, F.W.: A History of Montour County Pennsylvania. Berwick, PA, Keystone Publishing Co., 1970
5. Foulke, A.T.: My Danville. Quincy, MA, Christopher Publishing House, 1969
6. Bomboy, R.P., ed: Danville: The Bicentennial History. Haddon Craftsmen, Inc., 1991
7. Various documents and photographs in the possession of Ruth R. Browneller, and Jane M. Magill
